The Pressure to Conform

Richard Garstang
Richard Garstang
Managing Partner | Portfolio Manager

Richard Garstang

Managing Partner | Portfolio Manager

Richard Garstang joined OP in November 2006. He was previously employed by Man Securities as a research analyst covering the banking and specialty finance sector. He has also worked as a consultant for Deloitte in London and San Francisco. He graduated from St. Andrews University and is a CFA Charterholder. He is Managing Partner, co-manages the international portfolios, and contributes to the overall investment selection.

Richard Garstang

PDF

Active investment requires a willingness to look different. However, looking different can become highly challenging when markets move strongly against an investment philosophy.

For a value manager, that willingness has been tested many times. The late 1990s provide an extreme example. As technology shares continued to rise, value investors faced several years of increasingly painful underperformance. Tony Dye, then chief investment officer at Phillips & Drew, became perhaps the best-known casualty. He remained committed to his value-oriented approach and suffered badly. He left the firm in early 2000, remarkably close to the market peak.

Today, active managers face similar pressures. Artificial intelligence has contributed to a period of unusually concentrated equity market returns. At the same time, the enormous growth of passive investing has made the benchmark an increasingly visible and inexpensive alternative to active management. For managers whose investment philosophy leads them away from the companies driving those returns, looking different can become deeply uncomfortable.

That discomfort matters. Some managers change their approach deliberately. Others drift through a series of incremental decisions, each of which can appear entirely reasonable in isolation.

A company that previously looked too expensive is reconsidered. A painful underweight is reduced. A stock that might once have fallen outside the investment process becomes an acceptable exception. Any of those decisions may be correct. Collectively, however, they can produce a result that was never consciously intended.

This does not mean that an investment approach should stand still. A durable investment philosophy should provide a consistent framework for making decisions, but how it is applied will inevitably evolve. Markets change, companies change, and new technologies can alter growth rates, competitive positions and industry economics. New evidence should continually challenge individual investment conclusions without necessarily changing the philosophy behind them.

The difficulty is distinguishing between that natural evolution and a response to the discomfort of being different. The longer a challenging market environment persists, the harder that distinction can become. That raises a broader question: what allows an investment philosophy to be applied consistently through a full market cycle, while still allowing investment decisions to evolve as the facts change?

The Organisation Behind the Philosophy

Investment philosophies are often discussed alongside how they are implemented: valuation disciplines, research processes and portfolio construction. Less attention is paid to the organisation in which those things take place. Yet the structure surrounding an investment team can influence how successfully a philosophy is maintained over time.

Ownership is one part of this. In a partnership, where the people managing portfolios also own a meaningful part of the business, their economic interests are tied to its long-term health. A focused investment business built around a consistent philosophy may also have fewer competing organisational priorities, while capacity can be treated as an investment constraint rather than simply a commercial opportunity.

Client relationships matter too. A genuinely differentiated portfolio will inevitably experience periods when it underperforms its benchmark. Clients who understand why a portfolio looks different – and the pattern of returns that can follow – provide the time for an investment philosophy to be properly tested.

That differentiation can also have a role in broader portfolio construction. Clients often combine managers with different investment approaches precisely because they will not all perform well at the same time. Understanding the role each manager is intended to play can make periods of relative underperformance easier to withstand without undermining the purpose for which the manager was selected. Maintaining that consistency also matters to the integrity of the client’s broader portfolio: if a manager’s philosophy drifts, the exposure the client originally selected changes with it.

None of these characteristics confers investment skill. Ownership, incentives and patient clients cannot turn a bad stock into a good one. What they can provide is an environment in which investment decisions continue to be driven by the philosophy and the evidence, rather than by the desire to reduce the discomfort of looking different.

What This Means at Oldfield Partners?

Oldfield Partners was established on the belief that outperformance requires a willingness to look different from the index. Our portfolios are concentrated, our investment approach is valuation-led, and our investment professionals invest alongside our clients. The business remains majority owned by those who work at the company.

There have been periods when this approach has been distinctly out of favour. We have not responded by changing the philosophy, though we continually reassess the companies in our portfolios, and those outside them, as the evidence changes. Valuation has remained at the heart of how we invest.

At times, this leads us towards companies or industries that others regard as challenged or in decline. However, a value philosophy does not confine us to the ‘old economy’. We can find value in high-quality businesses and technology – our investments in several semiconductor companies being one example. What matters is not the industry or label, but the expectations embedded in the price.

Being willing to own what others avoid is, by its nature, uncomfortable. A shared investment philosophy therefore matters: our investment team has been built around people who believe in that approach and understand that periods of looking different are an inevitable part of applying it. We sometimes refer to this internally as having ‘value in the blood’.

Conclusion

We do not know when today’s concentration will end, or whether the companies currently leading markets will ultimately justify the expectations embedded in their valuations. AI could prove every bit as transformative as its strongest advocates believe.

The lesson from history is not that concentrated markets must reverse. It is that periods like this test investment philosophies. That pressure can be healthy, encouraging investors to challenge individual assumptions and reassess the evidence. But it can also encourage a manager to seek greater comfort: a little closer to the benchmark, a little less willing to tolerate painful differences, a little more willing to make exceptions.

The challenge for an active manager is therefore not simply to be different, but to remain true to an investment philosophy when that philosophy leads to a portfolio that looks very different from the market. Being different does not ensure better performance. But if an investment philosophy is to deliver differentiated outcomes over time, there will inevitably be periods when sticking with it is uncomfortable.

Partnership ownership, a team with shared beliefs, alignment between investors and clients, capacity discipline, and a clearly understood investment philosophy do not guarantee good decisions. They do, however, help provide the time and independence required to apply that philosophy consistently.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Important information

OP